incorrectshakespeare:

this has nothing to do with how much i like these plays (because i love many of the ones that i think are overrated and really dislike some that are underrated and vice versa) but here are a few for each category in my very humble opinion:

overrated: hamlet, romeo and juliet, othello, macbeth, a midsummer night’s dream
underrated: the comedy of errors, troilus and cressida, two gentlemen of verona, cymbeline, coriolanus

you can also read my informal guide to (many of) the plays here!!